Skip to Content
Opinion

Grading Our City Lakes: A Lesson for Our City

Citizens, agencies and local governments lifted Minneapolis lakes from failure to a triumphant C grade — a reminder that cooperation and compromise can restore not just waters but civic life. (Image: Courtney Cushing Kiernat)

Susan Lenfestey is a regular con­tributor. She lives in Lowry Hill.

After mats of aquatic weeds spread across Lake of the Isles this summer like mold on an old peach, it was a pleasant surprise to read that the C grade given by the Minnesota Department of Nat­ural Resources to our city’s Chain of Lakes is considered “a triumph of environmental restoration.”

Citizens, agencies and local governments lifted Minneapolis lakes from failure to a triumphant C grade -- a reminder that cooperation and compromise can restore not just waters but civic life. (Image: Courtney Cushing Kiernat)


How can such a mediocre grade be considered a triumph?
According to Greg Stanley, author of the August 16 article in the Star Tribune, a C would not be a good grade in the wooded and undeveloped parts of the state. But for the four city lakes that col­lect runoff from roads and urban development, the scores are re­markable.


Stanley writes, “By the 1990s, the lakes were in bad condition and getting worse. The marshes, woods, and prairies that once sur­rounded the chain had long been drained away and paved . . . Water clarity was declining. Algae blooms were frequent.”


“A Minnesota Pollution Con­trol Agency report found that Ce­dar Lake, the first in the chain, had nearly three times the phos­phorus it had before development. Along with that phosphorus, a toxic stew of pet waste, fertilizers, pesticides, chemicals, and oils was piped directly into the lakes from lawns and streets through storm­water systems.”


Then there was an amazing turnaround, thanks to citizens who took action, and the partner­ships that resulted.


“It was immediately clear that Minneapolis would not be able to fix the problem alone. Spurred on by citizens, the city formed a Clean Water Partnership with sev­eral agencies and organizations including the Minneapolis Park and Recreation Board, St. Louis Park, Edina, and the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District.”


According to Stanley, they di­vided up the $12.4 million cost of the restoration project and started work in 1995. This included dredging phosphorus-laden silt from smaller upstream lakes and creating ponds near the larger lakes to collect toxins and allow cleaner water to flow through.


“The city also increased its street sweeping program and started a public education cam­paign to cut down on the pesti­cides, grass trimmings, and fallen leaves washing into the lakes.”

That triumphant C grade also serves as a reminder of the days when realistic solutions mattered more than ideology, and comity was valued over combat.


That triumphant C grade also serves as a reminder of the days when realistic solutions mattered more than ideology, and comity was valued over combat.


It took good governance — creativity, collaboration, and com­promise — as well as an engaged group of citizens, to pull our lakes back from the brink.

Those three Cs are sadly miss­ing in today’s political grind.

Whether it’s the decrees ema­nating from the Oval Office, de­stroying partnerships and the planet with the stroke of a mad­man’s pen, or the ideological puri­ty required right here in River City’s DFL, we are also on the brink.

As with the lakes, the health of our city depends on civility and cooperation between its citizens. The Minneapolis DFL needs to address its dysfunction, laid bare in the debacle of its recent con­vention, and come up with an agenda that doesn’t alienate so many Minneapolitans who are tired of infighting and oratory, and just want the city to provide basic services, safe streets, and a level playing field for all. And clean lakes.

We are part of a shared water­shed. What happens upstream trickles down to us. How we con­duct ourselves as a city sends rip­ples across the state. We need to pull our oars as one, or at least stop using them as cudgels.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Hill & Lake Press

Holidays on Hennepin: A Monthlong Celebration of Uptown’s Reopening

Holidays on Hennepin will brighten the corridor from Nov. 28 to Jan. 1 with lights, events, and a business passport program celebrating the long-awaited reopening of Hennepin Avenue South.

October 25, 2025

Help Hill & Lake Press Carry Its Legacy Into Our 50th Year

As Hill & Lake Press nears its 50th anniversary, we’re inviting readers to help preserve nearly five decades of local history — supporting digitization, small businesses and the next generation of community journalism in Minneapolis’ lakes district.

October 25, 2025

Letters to the Editor

Community voices weigh in on the future of Minneapolis — from Uptown revitalization and park stewardship to setting the record straight on DFL leadership and supporting pragmatic, results-driven candidates for City Council and Park Board.

October 25, 2025

Wishing For Snow 

As another chaotic election season collides with an unseasonably warm fall, gratitude feels complicated. Between politics, climate change and human suffering, maybe the best we can do this Thanksgiving is find small moments of hope — and wish for snow.

October 25, 2025

‘Minneapolis for the Many’ PAC: Issues Apology to Local Landlord

The progressive PAC Minneapolis for the Many was forced to publicly retract and apologize after falsely labeling Minneapolis landlord Jim Rubin a “negligent landlord.” The group admitted its claims were untrue and acknowledged Rubin’s work to preserve older buildings and maintain naturally occurring affordable housing — a rare reversal in the middle of an already heated election cycle.

October 25, 2025

Temple Israel Defaced Again, Less Than a Year After First Incident

In a disturbing repeat of last year’s vandalism, Temple Israel was defaced again — this time with Hamas-linked graffiti on the second anniversary of the Oct. 7 attacks. Community leaders swiftly condemned the act as a hate crime, while police and the FBI launched an investigation into the antisemitic messages.

October 25, 2025
See all posts