Skip to Content
Feature Story

Catch of the Day

By Lori Mittag

11:55 PM CDT on September 1, 2025

Lori Mittag is a volunteer and lives in Kenwood.

It was a stormy morning when three brave kayakers set out to col­lect trash along the east side of Lake of the Isles.


Rob and Julie White are regulars at this noble task and, this time, brought along their neighbor, Jeff McNaught. Something unusual caught Julie’s eye while she was fill­ing three large bags of trash.


In her words, it was “bobbing up and down” in the water. It turned out to be a coin purse — a very soggy, very gross one.


Elizabeth Shaffer and I happened to be on shore for the East Isles cleanup when Julie tossed the purse up to me.


Elizabeth and I opened it, and the sleuthing began. Inside were a number of credit cards, coins, Toyota keys, a Medicare card and $200 in waterlogged cash.


The credit cards bore the name “Kar­la Thompson” and had expired in 2021. There was no driver’s license, but it was easy to guess that Karla was over 65 (Medicare card) and that the purse had been in the water at least four years (expired credit cards).


Elizabeth searched online and found two possible matches. I called the first one listed, a 69-year-old woman living in Plymouth. Jackpot — it was she!


Karla explained that she had lost the purse in 2020, during the pan­demic, while kayaking on Lake of the Isles. She was thrilled to have it back, especially since it had been a gift from her sister’s trip to Turkey.


The best part? The purse was made out of cork — which explained why it kept bobbing. Karla no longer owns the Toyota, but she is $200 richer, with extra money to buy beers at the Vikings game, where she was headed with her sister.

Lori Mittag reunites with her wallet, recovered years after it went overboard in Lake of the Isles. (Image: Jeff Mittag)

More Stories

October 2026 PDF

October 12, 2026

Uptown’s Worst Block Gets a Do-Over

The city admits that the 2018 redesign of Hennepin Avenue between Lake Street and 31st Street didn’t work. A quick fix with paint comes this fall, a real rebuild in 2028. I went to the open house to hear about it. So did a few dozen other people.

October 12, 2026

Renters Organize as Building Violations Pile Up

Tenants in five large apartment buildings describe lost heat, no hot water and mice. The city says enforcement has limits, and building owners did not respond.

October 12, 2026

Letters to the Editor

Our goal is to offer readers diverse perspectives on newsworthy events or issues of broad public concern to the Hill & Lake community. Our copy limit is 300 words (750 words for a commentary or as space permits), and we reserve the right to edit for clarity and length. We do not publish submissions from anonymous sources; all contributor identities must be verified.

October 12, 2026

School Board Election Matters

Quick, name a School Board candidate. Chances are you can’t! With a deficit of more than $39 million and school closings on the table, the two at-large seats on your November ballot deserve a closer look.

October 12, 2026

Dear MPS: “Trust Me, Bro” Is Not Good Governance

The district’s plan closes 14 to 16 schools, only saves about $700,000 and asks parents to take the rest on faith. A parent who has dated this guy before says: Show your work, bro.

October 12, 2026