Skip to Content
Dear Neighbor

Dear Neighbor

‘Tis the season: Let’s talk about wedding registries. I’m not a fan, but knowing how they proliferate, I suspect I’m in the minority.

This practice began in 1924 when Chicago’s Marshall Field’s instituted bridal registries for young ladies of the tony set to request china, crystal, and silver flatware – the trifecta of trousseaus. While it was a brilliant ploy by Marshall Field’s in that it worked and brought in gobs of money, a monster was born.

Giving wedding gifts is a tradition that’s been around for eons and can be traced to Ancient Rome. Back then, brides and grooms were considerably younger because the average lifespan hovered around 35, so if couples wanted to see their children grow up, they had them early in life.

Now, however, it’s a whole different ballgame. The average age of marriage for women is 27 and for men, 29. Add to that the fact that many couples are gainfully employed, have respective households or live together and already have everything they need.

The operative word here is need: Registries often focus on wants and can read like glorified letters to Santa. When a 5-year-old announces he or she wants a doll house or Lego® dinosaurs, it’s cute. When a 20-something solicits a $700 panini press, not so much.

Before we got married, both my future husband and I, well into our thirties, each had a fully-furnished house and given that we had everything we needed, the thought of asking for anything seemed insane. We worked for months diminishing our inventories and played the “Whose nicer?” game.

I had nicer living and dining room furniture; he sold his. He had a better microwave, TV, blender; mine went to St. Vincent DePaul. And so it went, whittling down our holdings to the point where, literally, two became one.

Even knowing this, friends and family nagged me to register. I declined because we didn’t need anything in particular. The response always was, “Well, how do I know what to give you?” Assuming you know at least one of the betrotheds, my advice is to figure out something at least one of the betrotheds, figure out something that speaks to them.

If they’re children of friends and you don’t know them well, give money; you can’t go wrong with that. The most important things to bring to a wedding and reception are your best wishes and sparkling personality.

Deep down, though, I fantasized about registering at Walgreens for laundry detergent, toothpaste, bar soap, dental floss (unwaxed) – things I could use and use up. And who wouldn’t love a gift certificate to the pharmacy?

The wonderful gifts we received were a set of hand-painted coffee cups and soup mugs from my dear friend, Jenny, and season tickets to the Jungle Theater from my dear friend, Mitch. I do remember a most puzzling gift: It was a set of wind chimes comprised of pink ceramic dolphins. I stared at them and wondered how things like this even get manufactured. But I remember them after lo, these many years, with the rosy attitude that holds that odd and unusual things make good stories.

Memo to the newly married couple: Write thank-you notes. This pronouncement has not changed. Gush over the towels and the hot dogscented candles and the clock in the shape of a foreign country because no matter how, your guest chose this gift for you. Write the notes with your own hand – no emails, no DMs, no phone calls, no texts, and for the love of God, no generic Facebook blast.

You have three months to get those letters in the mail, which is nothing compared to a lifetime of wedded bliss.

— Dorothy

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More Stories

September 2026 PDF

September 3, 2026

Adventures in Kindergarten: A Cautionary Tale

Choosing a kindergarten from fear sent one family four miles and nine hours a day away from home, until a five-block walk brought them back.

September 3, 2026

Loch Ness for Sale

A kinetic sculpture has kept watch over Cedar Lake since 1983. Now the sliver of land it stands on is on the market.

September 3, 2026

Letters to the Editor

Our goal is to offer readers diverse perspectives on newsworthy events or issues of broad public concern to the Hill & Lake community. Our copy limit is 300 words (750 words for a commentary or as space permits), and we reserve the right to edit for clarity and length. We do not publish submissions from anonymous sources; all contributor identities must be verified.

September 3, 2026

Bad Math: Why Underfunding Parks Doesn’t Add Up

The Park Board’s fiscal shortfall amounts to roughly one-tenth of 1% of the city’s proposed budget, a math teacher argues, and no line item delivers more for the money.

September 3, 2026

Lessons from Another Lake Street: What Can West Lake Street Learn from Midtown?

Three miles east of Uptown, Ingebretsen’s Anna Bloomstrand watched her stretch of Lake Street move from crisis to cooperation. What worked was not construction. It was a room where people knew each other.

September 3, 2026